
Written by Marie Myrie, Community Organiser
Exploring regeneration, rising housing costs, cultural identity and the impact of development on local and native communities.
Introduction: When development changes more than buildings
What does it mean to develop a community? Is it the construction of modern apartments, improved transport links, new shopping facilities and attractive public spaces? Or should development also be measured by whether the people who have lived in a place for generations can afford to remain there?
Across Jamaica and London (and many other cities worldwide), housing development is transforming landscapes, neighbourhoods and the lives of local residents. However, on my recent visit to Jamaica – I couldn’t help but feel the hostile environments of tourism taking over local beaches where community and native people of the land would once have free access. I think of my grandfather who was a keen fisherman and often would bring home enough fish to feed his family for the night. What would he have thought about privatisation of beaches in Jamaica in the name of tourist attraction. No doubt, he would likely pull a committee together and create a community-led action plan to prevent this since he was also a bit of a ‘local politician’ in his day – my father proudly and rightfully claims.
It would be hypocritical for me to say that I did not go and enjoy some of those private beaches whilst in Jamaica, they are a beautiful and serene experience – however, there was something lingering around it that didn’t quite sit right at times. It was an internal ongoing debate that I had throughout the trip – because there’s this thing around maintenance, safety and environmental care also just to name a few – however, does this outweigh locals and native families having access to what is rightfully theirs? Why can’t the government (and developers) instead, invest in the environment and upkeep of it’s natural beaches to ensure that it is both inclusive, well-maintained, safe and accessible. It does not sound like an impossible task – but perhaps not enough communities are asking so therefore it becomes easier to proceed to privatisation where the money is rather than the local people.
From the construction of new residential communities in East London, including Barking Riverside, to the expansion of housing developments across Jamaica, the language of progress is familiar: regeneration, investment, modernisation and opportunity.
Yet beneath these promises lies a difficult question: who benefits from development, and who risks being left behind?
Although Jamaica and London have different political histories, housing systems and relationships with land, both offer important lessons about the tension between economic development and the rights of established communities. In both places, a home is more than a financial asset. It represents family history, cultural identity, security and a sense of belonging.
As it stands, we are trying to live, thrive and/or survive in an increasingly difficult economy amongst developments that are lacking accessible community spaces, GP’s, affordable grocery stores, access to youth spaces as well as well-being and nature spaces. This is all without the mention of rising housing costs and unexplained service charges and bills, poor maintenance of new buildings – all leading to a huge gap in community empowerment, again – perhaps not enough communities are asking so therefore it becomes easier to proceed to privatisation where the money is rather than the local people.
When development fails to recognise these connections, the consequences can reach far beyond the property market. It can cause real devastation to families, local businesses and individual empowerment. Question is – how do you ask developers who are tied with millions in the bank to have compassion? Sounds simple yet challenging at the same time – but if we don’t ask it, the future becomes terrifyingly uncertain.