
by Matt Scott, CEO, Thames Life Community Development Hub

In 2016, Barking Riverside joined NHS England’s Healthy New Towns programme. The promise was a healthy, resilient community, with residents helping shape its future. Ten years on, that ambition deserves a reckoning.
Netflix’s Toxic Town dramatises families’ struggle for accountability over industrial contamination in Corby. It raises a question that reaches beyond Corby: what happens when the people expected to benefit from regeneration become inconvenient witnesses to its costs?
Barking Riverside’s environmental inheritance is documented. Parts of the development occupy former landfill that accepted asbestos and gasworks waste. Investigations recorded heavy metals, hydrocarbons and cyanide, with contamination reaching nearby watercourses. Remediation included treating and containing waste on site. That history makes continuing monitoring and public access to the results essential.
Nearby waste-burning facilities, expansion at Cory across the Thames and recognised flood risks demand scrutiny too. These facts do not establish that residents are being poisoned. They establish why “healthy” needs evidence behind it, and why residents’ questions deserve proper answers.
During the Barking Riverside Limited (BRL) planning proceedings on 16 March 2026,
https://lbbd.moderngov.co.uk/mgAi.aspx?ID=104945
planning consultant Ian Painting responded to concerns about air quality by referring to technical assessments within the Environmental Impact Assessment (EIA), which reportedly considered the impacts acceptable under relevant DEFRA and Mayor of London guidance. But this raises a more fundamental question: does the planning process adequately distinguish between compliance with statutory pollution limits and the protection of residents’ long-term health?
The World Health Organization’s (WHO) 2021 guidelines recommend an annual average concentration of just 5 µg/m³ for fine particulate matter (PM2.5), compared with the current UK legal limit of 20 µg/m³, while its guideline for nitrogen dioxide (NO₂) is 10 µg/m³ compared with the UK limit of 40 µg/m³. In both cases, the legal limit is four times the WHO’s health-based guideline. Compliance with these limits does not establish that exposure is risk-free. This distinction is particularly important for Barking Riverside, given its proximity to major waste-treatment infrastructure, including Cory’s operational Riverside 1 energy-from-waste facility, the Riverside 2 expansion and the Beckton sewage sludge incinerator. Their presence does not itself establish harmful pollution levels, but it makes transparent assessment of their contribution to cumulative air pollution and long-term exposure particularly important.
If Barking Riverside was designated a Healthy New Town, surely the measure of success should be whether residents enjoy the healthiest environment reasonably achievable, rather than simply whether pollution remains within legally permissible limits?
In a letter to the Ripple Effect Group on 21st March 2025 the previous BRL Managing Director responded to concerns by stating: “We are not responsible for the operation of facilities outside of Barking Riverside and you should direct any queries you have in relation to these to the Council or other relevant statutory authorities”.
Notwithstanding the fact that BRL is a partnership of the Greater London Authority and that, unlike the BRL managing director, airborne particulate do not make the distinction when crossing over into the BRL area of responsibility, the critical question is whether the planning assessments demonstrate that public health has been adequately protected, taking account of cumulative pollution, long-term exposure and the more protective WHO guidelines, rather than relying on regulatory compliance alone.
Concentrating these plants near Barking Riverside means a historically disadvantaged and low-income community is forced to bear the health risks and visual blight of burning London’s waste. This allows wealthier areas to ship their trash away while a growing, vulnerable population lives in its shadow, which directly violates the core principles of environmental justice.
Toxicity can also enter the way a place is governed.
In August, newspapers labelled Barking and Dagenham England’s “least friendly” place, drawing on measures of loneliness, belonging and civic participation. That headline overlooks the generosity we encounter daily. But the evidence of fraying social connection deserves attention. The ranking cannot establish its causes; it should prompt scrutiny of how power affects trust.
The drafting of a voluntary sector compact brings that question into focus. Can a charity challenge the council without fearing for its funding? Can it disagree with a developer without losing access or standing? A compact must give those freedoms practical protection.
A previous voluntary sector strategy was written by a council officer. In my view, that crossed a boundary: the sector should determine its own priorities and negotiate with the council from an independent position. When the institution we may need to challenge also writes our agenda, partnership risks becoming incorporation.
Fear of losing money can narrow what organisations feel able to say, even without an explicit threat. Co-option can happen through invitations, access and expectations of loyalty. Gradually, speaking for residents becomes speaking within the limits powerful partners will accept.
At Thames Life, we insist on the freedom to organise and challenge. That can carry a social penalty. My concern is that senior voices within the voluntary sector can reinforce council and developer expectations, leaving independent organisations isolated rather than defending their right to dissent. A mature partnership must be able to withstand disagreement. We don’t have that in our voluntary sector; we have patronage, compliance and exclusion. Imo.
Margaret Mullane MP recently told me that community organiser Arnie Graf, who had worked with her in Dagenham, described the borough as experiencing “social death”. For me, that captures the loss of confidence that acting together can change anything.
Our mandate is equitable regeneration. Our Resident Charter makes it concrete: genuinely affordable homes, a health centre, free community spaces, transparent governance, and protection for Footpath 47 and Ripple Nature Reserve. Every ask we made came with a solution and joint action. We weren’t just clear about what we didn’t want, every ask came with a solution and a shared action. But returning to the idea of social death and toxicity, in extreme times, the most powerful forces in an area don’t need solutions and shared actions to remain powerful.
There is every incentive to ignore, reject and ridicule such efforts the better to bolster already existing power. When asked to share such concerns in early 2024 with our local developer, we offered issues and actionable solutions, only to be told the concerns were “myths” that required ‘workshops in myth busting’. As John Gottman noted, the four destructive traits of communication – contempt, defensiveness, stonewalling and criticism, are alive and well amongst those leading infrastructure, communications and wider development locally.
Against that measure, I fear a trajectory towards domicide, ecocide and rivercide: the destruction of home and belonging, damage to living ecosystems, and degradation of the river and foreshore. A place can gain buildings while losing what makes it habitable.
Residents continue to organise, support neighbours and defend shared spaces. Thames Life stands with them in claiming the power to shape their own future. Our liberation cannot depend on accepting whatever crumbs others choose to offer.
A healthy new town must be safe to live in and safe to speak up in. Its voluntary sector must be free to help residents hold power to account. One thing I do know is that we must resist the social death Graf saw in the borough. What Arnie Graf might appreciate is that resistance is fertile, (never futile). Resistance tells us that people have not yet given up. The greater danger is when they do. The challenge for those with power, in the voluntary, public and private developer sectors, is therefore not how to manage dissent, but whether they are prepared to respond to what it is telling them. Something has to give. Without that, community risks becoming little more than a language through which power describes itself. From which developers generate PR to sell housing units with multiple hidden charges and little or no social infrastructure. With it, resistance might yet become the beginning of something different.
With it, collective action might yet become the beginning of something different. Even the mightiest walls can fall when the ripple becomes a wave. David defeated Goliath. And perhaps one day, when it is safe to speak out, when there is no social penalty, everyone will claim to have been against it all along. The tragedy would be if everyone finally found their voice only when it no longer mattered. But we are not waiting for permission. We can change things, we will change things, and together we are already making it happen.